Skip to Main Content

Well Maintained Buildings Sustain Ministry

Posted: February 26 2025 at 04:10 AM
Author: Sheryl Anderson, CPCU, ARM, member of NICUM Insurance Board


Tools 2145770 Cmyk

NICUM, the Northern Illinois casualty and liability insurance program, is the most economical and secure insurance option for conference churches. It covers a host of concerns. 

NICUM does not pay claims for maintenance-related damages, so it's wise to take good care of your church's property.

Under the terms of the policy, the insurance does not cover damages caused by cosmetic problems (e.g., building settling, cracking, shrinking, etc.) or the church’s failure to maintain the premises (e.g., wear and tear, rust, corrosion, erosion, fungus, decay, deterioration, wet or dry rot, and mold).

It is the church’s duty to maintain its property adequately so that the property’s condition does not invite damage or destruction. The insurance company does promise to make payment to the insured in the event of a loss covered by the policy (i.e., fire; lightning; explosion; windstorm or hail; smoke; aircraft or vehicles; riot or civil commotion; vandalism; leakage from fire extinguishing equipment; “sinkhole collapse;” “volcanic action;” falling objects; weight of snow, ice or sleet; or water damage).

It is a fact of life that a number of NIC church buildings are many decades old. Because of the age of these buildings, they have ongoing maintenance issues that must be addressed regularly. It is incumbent on a church and its board of trustees to continually assess the wellbeing of the church’s physical structure and a wide variety of supporting systems as to their integrity and ability to function. It is the church’s responsibility to address property deficiencies.

In order to have the greatest latitude in addressing building conditions, the church and trustees will benefit from taking a forward-minded approach to exploring funding and alternative planning options.

For instance, churches may be able to more aggressively save for anticipated future maintenance needs. By establishing such a reserve, the church will be in a better position to care for needs as they arise.

Some churches may find they can’t pay for necessary repairs through capital campaigns, general offerings, bequests, grants, or other fundraising activities. In this event congregations should work with their district superintendent to determine the best ways to continue to church’s ministries. This may necessitate considering options for using or finding space or sharing ministry with other congregations.

The NICUM board remains strongly committed to providing the optimum property and casualty insurance program for our member churches. This will be more affordable when churches commit to controlling risk as much as possible. When we work together to minimize risk, we will have more dollars available for ministry!

News & Announcements

Communion Elements

Order of Elders Share Experiences and Encouragement

About 100 elders gathered at Barrington United Methodist Church on March 25 for their annual order meeting.

Methodist Muslim Iftar 2025 4

Seeking Peace through Sharing and Caring

The Muslim Methodist Iftar Dinner was a heartfelt evening of unity, reflection, and shared commitment to peace. Embracing the theme “Seeking Peace Through Sharing and Caring,” faith lea…

Firstelginroof2025

Love of Neighbor Drives Elgin: First UMC's Recovery from Roof Loss

As storms raced across much of the Midwest late on March 14, 2025, what is believed to be a microburst tore half the roof off of the 101-year-old building of F…

Picture 5

UM Missionaries see lives changed in Asia and Africa

United Methodist Global Ministries missionaries Rev. Jonathan McCurley (Japan) and Rev. Dexter Ceballos (Mongolia) visited local congregations in February, sharing powerful…

Print