Skip to Main Content

Avoid the echo chamber and walk alongside other cultures

Posted: July 12 2024 at 12:40 PM
Author: Christa Meland, Minnesota Conference director of communications


“I have a confession to make,” Bishop Lanette Plambeck told hundreds gathered at the North Central Jurisdictional Conference in Sioux Falls, SD. “I’ve discovered in my assignment in the Dakotas-Minnesota Episcopal Area that I’m an edge walker.”

At opening worship on July 10, she explained that edge walkers are called to live and lead where two cultures meet.

Bishop Plambeck shared the story of going to dinner in Rapid City, SD, with two of her district superintendents last winter. She noticed on a nearby street corner was a group of American Indian siblings, some of whom were intoxicated—and a deep sense of both culpability and compassion simultaneously rose up in her. “Our Anglo ancestors brought in a substance that has decimated a community, and it was a crisis moment for me,” she said.

Bishopplambeckncj2024sm

Bishop Lynette Plambeck tells delegates to walk along the edges, where cultures meet

A short time later, three police cars showed up and officers began loading the men into their vehicles to take them to the local jail for the evening. Earlier that day, one of their Native siblings had frozen to death, and the officers recognized that if they arrested the men for the evening, they would be protected from the elements, and have a place to sleep and a meal to eat. “There is much confession in the midst of that,” the bishop noted.

She held out a braid of sweetgrass and explained that sweetgrass grows in ecotones—where two diverse ecological communities come together in rich, vibrant ways, and new life grows. This can happen where a forest meets a field or where a waterway meets land, for example.

Jesus, “the edge walker of all edge walkers,” knows the importance of ecotones, Bishop Plambeck told those gathered. He went to places where others wouldn’t go, saw people others wouldn’t see, and did something others couldn’t do: He created an ecotone that came to be known as the church—a church that was told, “You can’t just stay in Jerusalem. You have to go to Judea and Samaria and to the edges of the earth because you, church, are edge-walking people.”

“Aren’t we all edge walkers, called to be in that space called church?” Bishop Lanette asked? “It is important to claim who we are as edge-walking people because there are two things that can happen for the church: Either we become an ecotone or we become an echo chamber.”

The bishop said that Native pastors in Minnesota have been teaching her what it means to be a good relative, to admit hard truths, and to confess real sin. In fact, one taught her that the braiding of sweetgrass should never be done alone; one would get a better braid when two people working together.

The Dakotas-Minnesota Area is beginning to dream and scheme about how to partner with Native people, Bishop Lanette shared. The Minnesota Conference is planting two new Native ministries this year, and the Dakotas Conference is committing to walk alongside trafficked women and children.

“I have a confession to make,” Bishop Lanette said. “I know that North Dakota, South Dakota, and Minnesota are not the only lands with Native siblings residing. I know that this episcopal area is not the only area dreaming of new ways of being better siblings to those who were here first . . . We collectively have the opportunity to do a good thing.”

Braiding relationships together

We have an opportunity to be Jesus to others, she explained; people of joy and justice; people grounded in the teachings of John, Charles, and Susanna Wesley; people who sit alongside others, holding one end of the sweetgrass as they hold the other, braiding together relationships marked by grace, humility, and love.

At the very start of the conference, even before the first worship service, Bishop Plambeck highlighted the American Indian tribes that call the Dakotas home—and named some of the ways in which they have been harmed.

“We acknowledge that our churches have been built on the homelands of our Native siblings and their ancestors,” she said. “We took land and we gave boarding schools, smallpox, disease, alcohol. It is up to us to work to repair the damages of settler colonialism by sharing accurate histories, building and sustaining meaningful relationships with our Native neighbors, and working toward authentic acts of healing in the building of genuine relationships. North Central Jurisdictional Conference, we invite you to join with us in these efforts.”

She ended her message during worship with a final confession: “There’s so much for me to yet learn.” Alongside that confession, she made a commitment: “When we say to lift every voice, that we will do it, that we will lean into the story, that we will lean into learning, that we will lean into love.

“There is something about the goodness of God that the world is crying out for,” she said. “Let us not get caught in our own echo chamber, but let us take the culture, if you will, of the people called United Methodist and be intentional about getting alongside of other cultures . . . so that ecosystems, ecotones, can develop. We call that Beloved Community.”

Watch a recording of the sermon

News & Announcements

Vbs Galena Day 3 Vbs 2024 15 Cmyk

Creatively connecting over the summer

During the summer, many churches in Northern Illinois face declining attendance as families focus on vacations and outdoor activities. However, churches have found creative ways to engage…

Umc Dismantlingracismtownhall Aug 1080x1080 Fbad

From your Bishop: Resisting injustice through grace and love

‘Racism is incompatible with Christian teaching.’  ‘We are God’s daring alternative to fear and hate.’  ‘We walk the path of vulnerable love with the help of vulnera…

Picture 1 Volunteers Orientation Previous To Scd Cmyk

Radical Hospitality Provided to the SCD Participants

The first week of August was a powerful week for the NIC United Methodist community as we volunteered at the return of the School of Congregational Development (SCD) with D…

Measure Fingers 1850183 1280 Cmyk

Reimagining Church: Measuring Vitality?

For years, Christian Cook has been trying to figure out and codify ways that we can put together creative metrics to help get a sense of a church’s vital ministry. Worship attendance and…

Print